There's a stain on the cup, Will
Right where you used to stand
Red like the wine we were drinking
The bottle fell from your hand
Was it laughter or anger?
I can't remember now Just the look on your face when it happened
And the words you didn't say out loud
This stain won't come out No matter how hard I try
Sucked into the fabric Like the hurt in your eyes
I scrub and I pray But it only fades to grey
This permanent reminder
Of the night you walked away
I could cover it over
Move the furniture around
But I'd still know it's hiding there Underneath in the ground
The stain won't come out No matter how hard I try
It's soaked into the fabric Like the hurt in your eyes
I scrub and I pray
But it only fades to grey
This permanent reminder
Of what I can't erase
A stain on the cup A stain on my soul
Some things can't be forgiven