I didn't realize, till I got into it, till it got into meThat you couldn't handle this, but the way you came at meHad me so intrigued, I put my trust in youI don't know why, I just didYou seemed that type of guy, who took me seriousTo give love another try, cause I was curious in meI've been in and out, difficult relationshipsThis time I was so convinced, I let you into my lifeOh Lord, I really didn't wanna, can't help but give myself to yaThe first time that I saw ya, I thought that you was theDidn't care and you couldn't trust ya, cause there is no one else like yaYour smile, it melts me like butter, I thought that you was the sheDidn't take too long, I tried to hold onBut then the real you started to showAnd who would've ever thought, the one who had me soMesmerized would be the same one that I had to let goYou thought I'd come back around, when my guard was downAll of the whining and dining, all of that convincing meDidn't prove a thing, I knew one day that you'd miss meShould've known what to expect, disappointed but no regretsOh Lord, I really didn't wanna, can't help but give myself to yaThe first time that I saw ya, I thought that you was theDidn't care and you couldn't trust ya, cause there is no one else like yaYour smile, it melts me like butter, I thought that you was the sheI've been a fool for love once many timesYou were my everything, I can't go back with youAnd I ain't saying loving you ain't right, should've learned from my mistakesNow I gotta let you goI thoughtI thought that you was theOh Lord, I really didn't wanna, can't help but give myself to yaThe first time that I saw ya, I thought that you was theDidn't care and you couldn't trust ya, cause there is no one else like yaYour smile, it melts me like butter, I thought that you was the she