I'm walking out with my head down but I can't hide with these high heels on Downtown in a thick crowd but it's just you that my mind is on Dressed up, got my heart messed up, you got yours and I got mine It's unclear but I still care and I wonder where you are tonight Thinking it could be different, but maybe we missed it Thinking it could be different, it could, it could It should've been us, should've been the fire, should've been the perfect start It should've been us, could've been the real thing, now I'll never know for sure We were crazy, but it made sense, did it make sense now? It should've been us, it should've been us Should've been us, should've been us It, it, it should've been us Back and forth like a tug of war, what's it all for? Do I want it bad? I still got a little playing for you, even though you drove me mad Now and then I pretend that it's you when I close my eyes You got yours, I got mine, but I wonder where you are tonight It should've been us, should've been the fire, should've been the perfect start It should've been us, could've been the real thing, now I'll never know for sure We were crazy, but it made sense, did it make sense now? It should've been us, it should've been us Should've been us, should've been us It, it, it should've been us Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh Thinking it could be different, never been that sad Thinking it could be different, it could, it could, oh We were crazy, but it made sense, did it make sense now? It should've been us, it, it, it should've been us It should've been us It should've been us It should've been us, should've been the fire, should've been the perfect start It should've been us, could've been the real thing, now I'll never know for sure We were crazy, but it made sense, did it make sense now? It should've been us, it, it, it should've been us