You're giving me right, you're giving me wrongYou're selling me something that I'll never ownYou're giving me hope, you're leaving me coldYou're telling me nothing I don't already knowYou taught me to care for, and told me we'd winSo I took all I had, and I put it all inMy heart is here freezing, as my tears fill my bowlAnd I'm finally tasting aloneThis is the saddest vanilla that I've ever tastedThe saddest vanilla, and I don't wanna waste itSat at an ice cream parlor, you went and broke my heart, yeahNow I'm the saddest vanillaYou're giving me light, you're giving me darkYou told me the ending, right at the startYou're giving me something I sure ain't very used toYou're giving me blackout, you're giving me secretYou teased me with panic, you're giving me hellYou started running, the moment I fellMy heart is here freezing, as my tears fill the bowlAnd I'm finally tasting aloneThis is the saddest vanilla that I've ever tastedThe saddest vanilla, and I don't wanna waste itSat at an ice cream parlor, you went and broke my heart, yeahNow I'm the saddest vanillaSilly me, silly we, I thought you could be gentleUp and down, around and round, you're *** with my mentalI used to love to taste a bit, until you went and poisoned meAnd nowThis is the saddest vanilla that I've ever tastedThe saddest vanilla, and I don't wanna waste itSat at an ice cream parlor, you went and broke my heart, yeahNow I'm the saddest vanillaSaddest vanillaThis is the saddest vanilla that I've ever tastedThe saddest vanilla, and I don't wanna waste itSat at an ice cream parlor, you went and broke my heart, yeahNow I'm the saddest vanilla*