You'd say I'd see you in the movies
But I'd say
I'd probably sleep right through it
Way to play on the train to school
And,
oh,
messing around,
being so loud
We always said we were friends
I didn't know I liked you then You'd do the accent,
a proper New York gangster
You'd ask me questions,
but I couldn't answer,
oh
Cause I got tongue-tied when you said you were leaving
It brought up a feeling
I shouldn't be feeling
If it's not a heartbreak,
why do I feel broken?
Cup wide open from a love we never made
And if it's not a heartache,
when will I stop wanting
For you to call me darling and tell me I will be okay?
But it's not a heartbreak
Two years
since I last saw you
You seem different and I think I've changed, too
I've been building little futures It sounds stupid,
but they're mine
I wish I told you,
but I never told you If it's not a heartbreak,
why do I feel broken?
Cup wide open from a love we never made And if it's not a heartache,
when will I stop wanting
For you to call me darling
and tell me I will be okay?
But it's not a heartbreak
I didn't know I loved you then
I was scared to let you in How can you lose something you never had?
If it's not a heartbreak, why do I feel broken?
Cup wide open from a love we never made And if it's not a heartache,
when will I stop
wanting For you to call me darling and tell me I will
be okay?
But it's not a heartbreak
Why do I feel this way?