I was making an order at a coffee shop When she called my name, my heart just stopped
I said, I'll be damned if it ain't been ten long years
So we sat and we talked, babe, face to face For the first time since our glory days
And I didn't see him coming, but those feelings kept running
And it was pretty clear
I thought that she was just another girl, but she wasn't, she wasn't
I can't believe the way she had me buzzing, buzzing
I had to crash and burn so I could finally learn
I should have never let her go, and I know it, I know it
I'd give anything just to go back and show it
Thought that we were through and time would heal the wound, but it doesn't
I thought she was just another girl, but she wasn't
We were forty-five minutes into remembering
But when, when she reached for the sugar, she brushed my hand
And I wondered if she felt the fire that I did
I found myself lost in her eyes
Till just like that, it was closing time
She picked up the keys, and I couldn't believe
That I could be so blinded
I thought that she was just another girl, but she wasn't, she wasn't
I can't believe the way she had me buzzing, buzzing
I had to crash and burn so I could finally learn
I should have never let her go, and I know it, I know it
I'd give anything just to go back and show it
I thought that we were through and time would heal the wound
But it doesn't
I thought she was just another girl, but she wasn't, she wasn't
Yeah, she got into her car and she drove away
I said I guess you'll always be the one that got away
I thought that she was just another girl, but she wasn't
I can't believe the way she had me buzzing
I had to crash and burn so I could finally learn
So I could finally learn I should never let her go
Now I know it, I know it
Man, I'd give anything just to go back and show it
Thought that we were through and time would heal the wound
But it doesn't
Thought she was just another girl
Just another girl
But she wasn't
But she wasn't