I was a fool to let you in, knowing you would play with my heart Thought we were good, I thought we were good, thought we could make a new start You left me broken hearted, from the day your love departed Boy, this pain can't last, so take me back to you When it all seems so right, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right What you gonna do, baby? When it all seems so right, I was in love with you When it all seems so right, I was in love with you When it all seems so right, I was in love with you When it all seems so right Boy, you were different when you met me, holding my heart you touched so gently Now I'm cold inside, so empty, you left me So now when I wake and you're not there, and I gotta face what I had said How do I go on without you, baby? It's crazy Sitting reminiscing about a place and time, you've been playing on my mind Memories of yesterday When it all seems so right, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right What you gonna do, baby? I played the fool for you, baby, but you stole away my heart I played the fool for you, baby, but you played your part Sitting reminiscing about a place and time, you've been playing on my mind Memories of yesterday When it all seems so right, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right When it all seems so right, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right when it all seems so right, when it all seems so right I was in love with you, when it all seems so right