First I fell for your magic, like you were turning water into wine But the only spell you cast didn't end, must have made me blind Just like a siren you pulled me in just to watch me drown But baby I know now, you're just a heathen Just when I thought I was healing, you crawl back and mess with my feelings You're creeping inside my mind, you said this is the last time Girl I believed it, but you're just a heathen Hurt me once and you're the joker, forgive me twice and I'm the fool If I got the chance to start all over, we wouldn't be playing by your rules You're just a heathen Just when I thought I was healing, you crawl back and mess with my feelings You're creeping inside my mind, you said this is the last time Girl I believed it, but you're just a heathen I've waded through hell, but I'm burning still I'm over you wanting me under your spell I'm done breaking and bleeding, cause I'm finally seeing You're just a heathen You're just a heathen You're just a heathen You're just a heathen You're just a heathen You're just a heathen Heathen Heathen Heathen Heathen Heathen Heathen You're just a heathen Just when I thought I was healing, you crawl back and mess with my feelings You're creeping inside my mind, you said this is the last time And girl I believed it, but you're just a heathen You're just a heathen