I walked into the party looking all around
Danced all night in circles, you know where to be found
Blue kisses in the air, but none of them reached you
We ended and I befriended empty stools
I guess you didn't know the rules
Happy April Fool's
I thought you were too pure to fabricate
A hoax, so I waited all day long
For the punchline of your joke
But it never came, and that's when I knew
I had dwindled and you had swindled
My precious jewels
I guess I didn't know the rules
Happy April Fool's
I fell so hard for a trickster who told me his tricks would do me no harm
So I loaned him my sense of humor and now both my smile and laughter are gone
Your innocent prank always meant to be cruel
But baby, didn't they teach you in school
You can't make a fool of someone who's not true

Who's already a fool
You were always charming, knew just what to say
I fell into your trap like a lion and its prey
And when you showed your teeth, it was far too late
Legs were numb and I was as dumb as a heap of news
I should have known the rules
Happy April Fool's
Now I walk alone with my head up in the clouds
Faceless with no soul, holding hands with fear and doubt
They're my new best friends and I met them through you
Still you'll never be forgotten long as I stay haunted by ghosts and ghouls
I always knew the rules
Happy April Fool's
Oh, I fell so hard for a trickster who told me his tricks would do me no harm
So I'll never forget you

Found in my sense of humor and now both my smile and laughter are gone
Your innocent prank always meant to be cruel
But baby, didn't they teach you in school
You can't make a fool of someone who's already a fool
I said you can't make a fool of someone who's already a fool
No, no, you can't make a fool of someone who's already a fool