Come over to my house, jump in the neighbor's pool It felt nice, it felt so nice And it was getting dark, you wrapped your long legs around me I held on tight, lying in my bed The unfamiliar sheets were so cool on your skin When your daddy called, said you were out of friends And we walked the long way home Going on my first impression, I recall you wearing white There was something sweet in the air, babe That summer night, there will always be another time For us to fall in love, but it never cuts you quite as deep Is that first time? You'll find out that the deepest cut is the first time First time's always cut the deepest Read me with your hands, show me a safe place And I'll calm down, yeah I'll calm down And can you recognize the look upon my face? It's on my lips, it's in my eyes This bow will never break, won't you say it one more time? Won't you say my name? Won't you say my name? This bow will never break, won't you say it one more time? Won't you say, say my name? Going on my first impression, I recall you wearing white There was something sweet in the air, babe That summer night, there will always be another time For us to fall in love, but it never cuts you quite as deep Is that first time? You'll find out that the deepest cut is the first time First time's always cut the deepest Going on my first impression, I recall you wearing white There was something sweet in the air, babe That summer night, there will always be another time For us to fall in love, but it never cuts you quite as deep Is that first time? You'll find out that the deepest cut is the first time First time's always cut the deepest the first time You'll find out that the deepest cut is the first time First time's always cut the deepest the first time You'll find out that the deepest cut is the first time First time's always cut the deepest